Add code comment guidelines; dramatically trim excessive comments

CONTRIBUTING.md gains a "Code comments" section: comment the why not
the what, keep it to a sentence or two with a pointer to the load-bearing
evidence, don't re-derive a sibling's already-documented reasoning, and
move failed-attempt investigation logs out of inline comments.

Applied that policy across the codebase: condensed sprawling module
docstrings, per-entity essays, and multi-paragraph rationale blocks down
to their load-bearing conclusions, while preserving the actual "why"
(issue numbers, calibration evidence, gotchas, don't-guess rationale).
No functional code changed — verified via diff review, ruff, ty, and the
full pytest suite (1211 passed).

One inline investigation log (the AC filter-reset "tried and failed"
notes) moved to docs/investigations/ac-filter-reset.md rather than being
deleted, per the new guideline on where that kind of record belongs.
This commit is contained in:
Marc Billow committed 2026-08-05 01:24:17 +00:00
1 parent f8a7a1fa66
commit 7086b134c0
36 files changed
+2127 -3598

No files matched your search

+75
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,75 @@
# AC filter-time counter reset: not solved
`registry/capabilities/airconditioner.py`'s `filter_time` sensor
(`FilterTime_<N>` option token, tenths of an hour) has no reset entity. This
is where the failed attempts to find one are kept, so the next attempt starts
from the evidence instead of from scratch. Not finding a mechanism is not the
same as it not existing.
## What the reset actually is
Samsung models it as a **command**, not a value write: capability
`custom.dustFilter`, command `resetDustFilter`, no arguments (implemented in
several SmartThings HA forks; not in the core integration). That reframes
every attempt below — nothing changes the counter by writing to it, because
the board zeroes it itself on receiving a command.
## Tried, all against a live unit, all failed
- `FilterTime_0` via the single-token options merge that works for every
other setting on this href — accepted with no error, then discarded. Tried
on two units in opposite power states to rule out the obvious confound:
5595 → back to 5595 after 69s (powered off, alarm active), 1925 → back to
1925 after 65s (actively cooling).
- A full `options[]` read-modify-write with `FilterTime_0` substituted,
instead of the single-token merge — zero fields changed anywhere.
- A write to `/consumable/vs/0`, the board's own filter resource
(`items[{name: FilterProgress, state: N}]`) — discarded. `/oic/res`
declares that resource `oic.if.s` (read-only), which fits.
- `/actions/vs/0` (`x.com.samsung.da.actions`, `oic.if.a`) is the obvious
local command channel but publishes no schema: GET returns `{}` on
baseline and on `oic.if.a`, and five POSTs probing the shape (empty map,
empty string, empty array, invalid value, items shape) all returned 4.00
with an empty body — no echo of accepted field names, unlike the laundry
firmware's `"Control fail, <...>"`. Guessed action names were deliberately
not enumerated against a live appliance: an unknown vocabulary on a
channel called "actions" can hold a factory reset next to the one we want.
- `/hass/state/vs/0` and `/hass/command/vs/0` (advertised in `/oic/res`, and
`/opt/data/hass.db` exists in `/file/list`) → 4.04 on every interface, so
unimplemented scaffolding on this firmware.
- `/file/transfer/vs/0` serves only `/mnt/usage.db`; selecting another path
returns 4.05/4.00, so the firmware can't be pulled that way to read the
action vocabulary out of it.
- `/rm/micomdata/vs/0` (channel toward the MICOM board the physical panel
talks to) stays empty even after successfully enabling remote management.
## What the failures are not
Not a transport, permission, or cert problem: a control write of `rmState`
on `/rm/state/vs/0` was accepted (2.04 Changed, value held, restored
afterwards), and `FilterAlarmTime_` is written through the very same options
merge and kept. Writes work; this one value just isn't driven that way.
## Where to look next
- The `/actions/vs/0` action vocabulary from an independent source (a
firmware image, or a capture of what the cloud sends the device).
- The IR path — the physical remote has a filter reset (Options → Filter
Reset → SET), and IRremoteESP8266 decodes this AC family, though issue
#1277's dump doesn't include that button.
## Evidence for the counter's direction and scale
Confirmed counting *up* (running time since last reset, not remaining time):
token 1710 matched the Samsung app's "171 hours 0 minutes" for the same
filter (pins the tenths-of-an-hour scale); seen rising while the unit ran
(171.0 → 171.5); and across two units on one site the `/alarms/vs/0` filter
alarm tracks the counter in the right direction — live (`FilterAlarm`,
`Created`) at `FilterTime_5595`, still the `FilterAlarm_OFF`/`Deleted`
placeholder at `FilterTime_1915`, matching the app's own 500-hour threshold
behavior. `FilterAlarmTime_` in the same options blob is that threshold (500
on every unit on record).
The entity key stays `filter_time` rather than `filter_time_elapsed`:
renaming it would change every existing unit's `entity_id`/`unique_id` for a
wording improvement only.