Update adding-device-support skill for /oic/d as primary detection

The skill still described oneUiVersion-era two-stage detection and said
"nothing routes on /oic/d yet" -- both stale now that resolve() checks
device_types first. Rewrite the routing section around the new three-stage
order, add a dedicated "Adding an /oic/d device type" section documenting
the right endpoints (/oic/d, /oic/p, /oic/res) and the issue-confirmed vs
OCF-spec provenance convention, and add explicit checklist reminders (in
the routing section and in "Lock it in") to check and fill in
_OIC_TYPE_TO_KEY whenever a dump carries a type.
This commit is contained in:
Marc Billow
2026-07-31 01:03:29 +00:00
parent 0a4b80afc4
commit 9f4c47ea63
+94 -20
View File
@@ -5,8 +5,9 @@ description: >-
/device/0 diagnostics dump. Use when a device-support issue lands, a device
raises the "incomplete capability coverage" repair, a diagnostics JSON needs
triaging, or you're mapping OCF resources to HA entities. Covers reading dumps,
routing an unrecognized board family to a registry (modelNum board tokens,
resource signatures),
routing a device to a registry from its `/oic/d` device type first and an
unrecognized board family second (modelNum board tokens, resource
signatures),
OCF-standard vs vendor hrefs, the diagnostic/config/normal entity taxonomy,
preferring dynamic (device-reported) select options over hardcoded lists,
ensuring every href is bound or ignored, and locking it in with a fixture +
@@ -64,8 +65,13 @@ by_type = importlib.import_module('custom_components.localthings.registry.by_t
discovery = importlib.import_module('custom_components.localthings.registry.discovery')
adapter = importlib.import_module('custom_components.localthings.registry.adapter')
resources = json.load(open('dump.json'))['data']['resources']
reg = by_type.resolve(resources) # the same entry point the coordinator uses
data = json.load(open('dump.json'))['data']
resources = data['resources']
# identity.device_types is /oic/d's `rt` -- resolve()'s primary signal (see
# §3). Absent on dumps predating that field; () falls through to model-based
# detection exactly like a device that reports nothing there.
device_types = tuple((data.get('identity') or {}).get('device_types') or ())
reg = by_type.resolve(resources, device_types=device_types) # the same entry point the coordinator uses
unbound = []
bound = discovery.discover(resources, reg.capabilities, reg.pattern_capabilities, log=unbound.append)
state = adapter.flatten(bound, resources) # {entity_key: value}
@@ -90,15 +96,21 @@ loses roughly **half** its entities (measured across the fixture corpus: 843 of
1510 bound entities survive). So routing is the first thing to fix, and
`registry/by_type/__init__.py` is deliberately kept boring.
`resolve(resources)` is the only entry point — the coordinator, the config
flow's probe and the golden-regression harness all call it, so the order can't
drift between what ships and what the tests assert. Two stages:
`resolve(resources, device_types=())` is the only entry point — the
coordinator, the config flow's probe and the golden-regression harness all
call it, so the order can't drift between what ships and what the tests
assert. Three stages, most-specific evidence first:
1. **`for_device_by_model(model_num, description)`** — the primary path. Both
fields come from `/information/vs/0`. Board-family tokens are matched
against `modelNum` first, then `description`, then the fuzzy two-letter
consumer-model prefix.
2. **`for_device_by_resources(resources)`** — for boards that report no
1. **`for_device_by_oic_type(device_types)`** — the primary path whenever a
dump has it. `device_types` is `/oic/d`'s `rt`, looked up against
`_OIC_TYPE_TO_KEY`. The device naming its own type beats parsing board
part numbers, so this always wins when it hits. **Always check this first
when triaging a new dump** — see "Adding an /oic/d device type" below.
2. **`for_device_by_model(model_num, description)`** — the fallback for
everything `/oic/d` doesn't resolve. Both fields come from
`/information/vs/0`. Board-family tokens are matched against `modelNum`
first, then `description`, then the fuzzy two-letter consumer-model prefix.
3. **`for_device_by_resources(resources)`** — for boards that report no
`/information/vs/0` at all. Needs a *distinctive* signature.
**`oneUiVersion` is not consulted.** It looks like the obvious signal — the
@@ -152,15 +164,65 @@ Reach past the table only when the evidence isn't a board token:
(e.g. `/oven/vs/0` present *and* a `MicroWave*` entry in `supportedModes`),
never one, or an unrelated family's `/mode/vs/0` will match.
### If the model string identifies nothing
### Adding an /oic/d device type
Check the diagnostics `identity` block before inventing a rule: it carries
`/oic/p` and `/oic/d`, which sit outside the `/device/0` dump.
`identity.device_types` is `/oic/d`'s `rt` — OCF's own device-type
declaration (`oic.d.airconditioner`). Nothing routes on it yet because no
captured dump has ever included it; if real hardware turns out to populate it,
it beats parsing board part numbers and this whole section shrinks. Note in
the issue when a dump has it.
`/oic/d`'s `rt` (OCF's own device-type declaration) is the *primary*
detection path (`for_device_by_oic_type`, stage 1 above) — it sits outside
the `/device/0` dump, read separately by `registry/identity.read_identity`,
which fetches three endpoints in one shot:
- **`/oic/d`** — the device type itself: `n` (device name) and `rt`, a list
carrying the generic `oic.wk.d` base type every OCF device has alongside a
concrete one (`oic.d.airconditioner`) or a SmartThings vendor extension
(`x.com.st.d.stickcleaner`, for categories with no `oic.d.*` equivalent —
same prefix convention as `x.com.samsung.da.*` resource fields elsewhere).
- **`/oic/p`** — platform identity: `mnmn`/`mnmo` (manufacturer/model).
- **`/oic/res`** — resource discovery, used for subdevice enumeration (§11),
not device typing.
None of the three appear in `resources`; find them in diagnostics' `identity`
block (`identity.device_types`, `identity.manufacturer`, `identity.model`),
or read live with `read_identity(sess, serial)` if you're driving a device
directly.
**Whenever you triage a dump, check `identity.device_types` before touching
`_BOARD_TOKEN_TO_KEY` at all** — the whole point of this stage running first
is that a real `/oic/d` type makes board-token routing unnecessary. Two
outcomes:
- The type is already a key in `_OIC_TYPE_TO_KEY` (`registry/by_type/__init__.py`)
→ detection already works; an unbound-hrefs gap on this device is a
capability-coverage problem (§§4–9), not a routing one.
- The type is **not yet in the table** → add a row. This is now the
integration's primary detection method, and it only stays that way if new
types get folded in as real dumps surface them — same discipline that
keeps `_BOARD_TOKEN_TO_KEY` current:
```python
'oic.d.dishwasher': 'dishwasher', # OCF spec
'x.com.st.d.steamcloset': 'air_dresser', # AirDresser / steam-closet garment care
```
- **Mark provenance in a trailing comment.** `# issue #N` for a string seen
verbatim in a real dump; `# OCF spec` for one not seen yet but defined by
the OCF Smart Home Device Specification's Table 9-1 with the exact same
`oic.d.<category>` shape as an already-confirmed entry — that shape is
low-risk to add ahead of a dump because, unlike a board-token entry, there's
no tokenizing or delimiter-spelling judgment call involved.
- **Only add a row once there's a real registry key on the right** (a key in
`_REGISTRY_BY_KEY`). A type naming a product this integration has no
registry for stays unmapped rather than getting coerced onto the
nearest-sounding one — `oic.d.robotcleaner` names an actual robot vacuum,
a different product from the clean/auto-empty *station* `vacuum_station`
covers (no vacuum-body capabilities at all; see that registry's own module
docstring), so it's deliberately absent even though the string is known.
- Falls through to `for_device_by_model`/`for_device_by_resources` when
`device_types` is empty or maps to nothing — most hardware still doesn't
populate `/oic/d` usefully, so those two stages stay load-bearing for
everything this one doesn't catch.
- On a multi-subdevice appliance, `device_types` only ever comes from the
*master's* `/oic/d` (`discover_partitioned`'s `oic_device_types` param) —
subdevices have no `/oic/d` of their own read today and keep resolving from
their own `/information/vs/0`, falling back to the master's whole registry
otherwise (§11).
### Sharing a registry vs adding one
@@ -332,6 +394,13 @@ shared module rather than copying.
## 10. Lock it in
If the dump's diagnostics `identity` block carries a `/oic/d` device type,
confirm (or add, per "Adding an /oic/d device type" in §3) the matching
`_OIC_TYPE_TO_KEY` row before considering this device done — routing this
device by board token today doesn't mean the next report of the same
appliance family gets the faster, more reliable `/oic/d` path unless the
table actually has the row.
1. Add a **scrubbed** fixture `tests/fixtures/<type>_device.json`
(`{"device0": [ {devcol rep}, {href, rep}, ... ]}`) — replace serials, MACs,
and other PII with placeholders.
@@ -458,6 +527,11 @@ devices it *does* provide refuse removal, since HA would just recreate them.
Tell the reporter to delete the stale device, don't add a pruning pass.
## Key files
- `registry/identity.py` — `read_identity`, `DeviceIdentity.device_types`
(`/oic/d`'s `rt`), the primary device-type signal's source.
- `registry/by_type/__init__.py` — `resolve()`, `for_device_by_oic_type` and
`_OIC_TYPE_TO_KEY`, `for_device_by_model` and `_BOARD_TOKEN_TO_KEY`/
`_CONSUMER_PREFIX_TO_KEY`, `for_device_by_resources`.
- `registry/subdevices.py` — `Subdevice`, enumeration, canonical ⇄ actual href
translation, and the materialization gate for multi-subdevice appliances.
- `registry/discovery.py` — `discover()`, unbound reporting, pattern caps.